First of May: A Song that Sparked a Family Feud (and Became a Hit)

“First of May” by the Bee Gees is more than just a catchy tune. It’s a song entrenched in the group’s history, marking a turning point in their relationship.

Released in 1969 as the only single from their ambitious double album “Odessa,” “First of May” became a substantial hit in the UK, reaching the top 10. However, its success came at a cost. The song became a point of contention between brothers Robin and Barry Gibb.

While Robin championed “Lamplight” for the A-side, a song with a prominent Robin vocal, their manager, Robert Stigwood, favored the orchestral and melancholic “First of May” with lead vocals by Barry. This disagreement ultimately led to Robin’s temporary departure from the group.

Despite the internal conflict, “First of May” showcased the Bee Gees’ evolving sound. It was a departure from their earlier pop hits, venturing into a more baroque and dramatic territory with its lush arrangements and unconventional ending.

The song’s title, interestingly enough, has a rather mundane origin. According to Barry Gibb, it was inspired by the birthday of his and his wife’s dog, Barnaby.

“First of May” stands as a bittersweet reminder of the Bee Gees’ internal struggles. Though it caused a temporary rift, the song’s enduring popularity and Robin’s eventual return solidified the group’s success. “First of May” serves as a bridge between their earlier pop sensibilities and the more mature sound they would embrace in the decades to come.