Conway Twitty’s “It’s Only Make Believe”: A Heartfelt Plea Hidden in a Country Classic

Conway Twitty, a legend in the world of country music, delivered a timeless ballad in 1958 with “It’s Only Make Believe”. This deceptively simple song, with its catchy melody and smooth vocals, explores the complexities of unrequited love and the emotional toll it takes.

The lyrics paint a picture of a lovestruck individual who is painfully aware that their affection isn’t reciprocated. “People see us everywhere/ They think you really care” sings Twitty, highlighting the facade they maintain for the outside world. Despite the outward appearance, the singer confesses, “Myself, I can’t deceive/ I know it’s only make-believe.” This line cuts deep, revealing the protagonist’s internal struggle between hope and harsh reality.

The song’s emotional core lies in the repeated plea, “My one and only prayer/ Is that someday you’ll care”. Twitty’s voice, brimming with sincerity, conveys the depth of the protagonist’s love and their desperate hope for a change of heart. The lyrics, “My hopes, my dreams come true/ My one and only you”, further emphasize the all-consuming nature of this unrequited affection.

“It’s Only Make Believe” doesn’t dwell on anger or resentment. Instead, it focuses on the quiet desperation of loving someone who doesn’t love you back. The line, “No one will ever know/ How much I love you so”, speaks volumes about the protagonist’s emotional vulnerability and the burden of unspoken feelings.

Despite the melancholic tone, the song maintains a glimmer of hope. The repeated refrain, “It’s only make believe”, can be interpreted in two ways. On one hand, it acknowledges the current state of their relationship as a pretense. On the other hand, it suggests a sliver of optimism, a belief that perhaps someday their love could become real.

“It’s Only Make Believe” is more than just a country love song; it’s a universal tale of unrequited affection. Twitty’s masterful performance captures the heartache and vulnerability of loving someone from afar, making this song a timeless classic that continues to resonate with listeners across generations.

Video